| Platinum | Romios Pizza & Pasta |
| Gold | Giorgio's Pizza & Spaghetti House |
| Silver | Amante Pizza & Pasta |
| Bronze | Capers + Olives |
| Top Pick | Alfie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Beverly Pizza |
| Top Pick | Buca Di Beppo |
| Top Pick | Contos Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Gianni's Ristorante Italiano |
| Top Pick | Lombardi's Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar |